• Latest
  • Trending
Minibus taxis in Alexandra township, Johannesburg.

Subsidies for South Africa’s minibus taxis must prioritise needs of passengers – and cities

November 16, 2020
Johannesburg traffic roads

Challenges facing road users at Maalgate River Bridge R102 project

April 13, 2021
road accidents

Reduction in road accidents

April 8, 2021
NTA still waiting for Mbalula’s response to demands

Transformation imperative in aviation: Mbalula

April 8, 2021
Minibus taxis in Alexandra township, Johannesburg.

Santaco says ‘No’ to taxi fare increase while NTA gives it a thought

April 8, 2021

Gautrain offers student travel pass discounts

April 7, 2021

Most South Africans prefer travelling by foot

April 7, 2021
Integrated transport

Gauteng may give taxis a reprieve on e-tolls

April 7, 2021
NTA still waiting for Mbalula’s response to demands

Limpopo and Gauteng record high deaths during Easter

April 6, 2021
Ford SA lends helping hand to fight against Covid-19

Ford SA lends helping hand to fight against Covid-19

March 31, 2021
Toyota upgrades its Hiace Ses’fikile and improves Covid-19 driver guard

SATAXI introduces incentive scheme for taxis

March 31, 2021
DiDi

Chinese Uber Competitor DiDi Chuxing Expands To Cape Town

March 29, 2021
Uber

Uber driver behind bars for hijacking and kidnapping

March 24, 2021
Profit margins in South Africa’s minibus taxi industry have been under pressure long before the COVID-19 lockdown. Karel Prinsloo / AFP via GettyImages

Zululand taxi industry mourns King Goodwill Zwelithini 

March 24, 2021
Minibus taxis in Alexandra township, Johannesburg.

KwaZulu-Natal taxi association fights illegal operators

March 24, 2021
A Taxi Foundation in collaboration with POWA

Corporate collaborations join forces with POWA to fight GBV

March 23, 2021
taxis

Limpopo taxi body gets life back under level one

March 8, 2021
Juliet Mamqibela Murembiwa

The Iron Lady from Limpopo hails taxi industry 

March 8, 2021

Stats SA shows taxis now take more taxis 

March 8, 2021
Minibus taxis in Alexandra township, Johannesburg.

Taxi industry welcomes the easing of restrictions

March 8, 2021
Uber

Uber drivers in South Africa: employees or independent contractors?

March 3, 2021
Volvo C40 Recharge

Meet The New, Pure Electric Volvo C40 Recharge

March 3, 2021

Toll tariffs adjusted to 3.39% inflation rate

February 24, 2021
Taxi industry to plead for early vaccination 

Taxi industry to plead for early vaccination 

February 18, 2021
taxis

SA Taxi officially opens its doors to drive Mbombela forward

February 18, 2021
NTA still waiting for Mbalula’s response to demands

NTA still waiting for Mbalula’s response to demands

February 15, 2021
COVI19

KwaZulu-Natal suspends major events as Covid-19 wrecks havoc

February 15, 2021
taxis

Taxi industry new fight against potholes

February 15, 2021
A policeman stands guard during a protest by minibus taxi operators against a new bus service for Johannnesburg. Alexander Joe/AFP via Getty Images

Diepmeadow chairman dies under mysterious circumstances

February 15, 2021
Minibus taxis in Alexandra township, Johannesburg.

Taxi operator lives in fear of losing vehicle to the bank

February 15, 2021
A policeman stands guard during a protest by minibus taxi operators against a new bus service for Johannnesburg. Alexander Joe/AFP via Getty Images

Warring Limpopo taxis cool off after MEC intervention 

February 15, 2021
  • Contact us
  • Advertise Here
  • Login
Gibela Transport Magazine
Advertisement
ADVERTISEMENT
  • Home
  • Airports
  • COVID-19
  • Editorial
  • Government
  • Rail
  • Taxis
  • Tenders
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Airports
  • COVID-19
  • Editorial
  • Government
  • Rail
  • Taxis
  • Tenders
No Result
View All Result
Gibela Transport Magazine
No Result
View All Result
ADVERTISEMENT
Home Government

Subsidies for South Africa’s minibus taxis must prioritise needs of passengers – and cities

Staff Writer by Staff Writer
November 16, 2020
in Government, Public transport, Taxis
4 0
0
Minibus taxis in Alexandra township, Johannesburg.

Minibus taxis in Alexandra township, Johannesburg. Andrea Lindner/picture alliance/Getty Images

10
SHARES
16
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

by Benjamin H. Bradlow and Herrie Schalekamp

South Africa’s transport minister, Fikile Mbalula, has confirmed his commitment to implement a new subsidy for the country’s minibus taxi sector. For the first time, he also provided a timeline for the proposal, promising to work with the national treasury and the taxi sector to put the subsidy in place by April 2021.

Mbalula has described the prospect of this subsidy as a “new dawn”. But the design of the subsidy that has been reported so far suggests something much more familiar.

The approach is largely geared towards financing the improvement of the “capital” stock of the sector, such as upgrading vehicles. As we have both previously written, successful reform in the taxi sector is unlikely without a concurrent focus on providing incentives for the industry to change the way it operates.

This is not the first time that government has provided a capital subsidy to the sector. The first was with the “recapitalisation programme” of 1999, which is still active. The recap programme provides a one-off contribution to buying a new minibus. It appears that the new proposed subsidy will be similar, but with a more sustained model of continuous financing available to upgrade vehicles.

We believe that the motive behind the proposed subsidy is problematic. This was articulated by President Cyril Ramaphosa in his remarks in support of Mbalula’s plans:

Given its financial size, formalising the taxi industry is a vital step towards ensuring its contribution to the national tax revenue base.

If the main purpose of subsidising and formalising the taxi sector is to bolster operators’ finances so that they pay more taxes, it is doomed to fail. South Africans should not imagine that providing more money to the taxi sector is going to change the national government’s problems with revenue generation.

Moreover, this goal does not address the main reason for subsidising the taxi sector: to provide cheap, frequent and quality public transport so that all people can access and generate economic opportunity in South Africa’s cities.

We propose that any new subsidy should address this fundamental goal of equitable access.

Solving the real problems

By its definition, a subsidy that works towards the goal of safer and wider access must prioritise operational, as opposed to capital, support. As government itself admits, persistent problems that need to be addressed are shoddy customer service and poor passenger safety. These result largely from the way that drivers need to chase after passengers to earn a decent income.

Newer vehicles are indeed safer. But the taxi recap programme’s capital subsidy by itself will not remove drivers’ incentive to speed. Nor does it change where and when passengers can travel.




Read more:
Why operational subsidies are key to reforming South Africa’s minibus taxi sector


To be clear, we are not saying that it is a bad idea to formalise and support the taxi sector. From a public interest perspective it makes sense. Government already does so for rail and bus services which, combined, serve less than half the number of people who use minibus taxis.

But this support should be given in a way that enables a more user-friendly form of service while also taking into account the taxi sector’s organisational structure.

The basic unit of a taxi business comprises the owner, driver and vehicle. Their operating relationship with the state is regulated by way of an operating licence awarded to owners and that is connected to their specific vehicles.

South African Transport Minister Fikile Mbalula.
GCIS/Flickr

Daily revenue is managed between the vehicle driver and owner. They have limited links to the various taxi associations that control the routes, or the national representative council, the South African National Taxi Council. The collective bodies do not have a formal or regulated role to play in how each taxi business’s financial flows are managed.

Role of municipalities

SA Taxi, the largest financier in the sector, with loans to 25,000 taxi owners, estimates that there are 200,000 to 250,000 minibus taxis in the country. The same figures indicate that each business has a fleet of 1.2 vehicles on average. This suggests that, nationally, there could be over 200,000 individual taxi businesses.

It is impossible for the provincial regulatory authorities, or the national government, to institute and administer contracts and operating subsidies to each of these businesses.

On the other hand, metropolitan municipalities (metros) are a useful institutional scale in which to manage some of these issues. They may have some administrative capacity constraints. But the National Land Transport Act of 2009 also provides metros with currently under-utilised authority in this area.




Read more:
South Africa’s minibus taxi industry has been marginalised for too long. This must change


The introduction of an operational subsidy could help give individual businesses an incentive to form collective companies that afford significant independence. At the same time it would still accommodate a more formalised regulatory and financial relationship with the municipal level.

We propose that the establishment of municipal transport authorities could provide a more appropriate institutional venue for managing an operational subsidy as well as to contract services with the new collective business entities.

No silver bullet

Operating subsidies are not a silver bullet. But the taxi sector is an unavoidable and central part of the mobility landscape in urban South Africa. Operating subsidies could be a powerful tool for breaking the low-level equilibrium that we have argued is holding back opportunity for both users and operators.

Another capital subsidy is not likely to change this dynamic.

On the other hand, context-appropriate operational subsidies could play a role in kick-starting new institutional experiments that could get the sector — and collective transport in South Africa’s cities more generally — on a more user-friendly and coordinated footing.The Conversation

Benjamin H. Bradlow, Postdoctoral Fellow, Weatherhead Center For International Affairs, Harvard University and Herrie Schalekamp, Research Officer in Transport Studies, University of Cape Town

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

Would you like to hear more about this? You can subscribe here ...

Unsubscribe
Staff Writer

Staff Writer

Related Posts

Johannesburg traffic roads
Roads

Challenges facing road users at Maalgate River Bridge R102 project

by Mokgalwane Mogano
April 13, 2021
Minibus taxis in Alexandra township, Johannesburg.
People

Santaco says ‘No’ to taxi fare increase while NTA gives it a thought

by Giyani Shivambo
April 8, 2021
People

Gautrain offers student travel pass discounts

by Mokgalwane Mogano
April 7, 2021
Integrated transport
eTolls

Gauteng may give taxis a reprieve on e-tolls

by Mokgalwane Mogano
April 7, 2021

Latest

  • All
  • Taxis
  • Rail
Minibus taxis in Alexandra township, Johannesburg.

Taxi operator lives in fear of losing vehicle to the bank

February 15, 2021
SA Taxi commemorate International Anti-Corruption Day

Taxis are Covid-19 carriers: warn Limpopo MEC

February 15, 2021
Profit margins in South Africa’s minibus taxi industry have been under pressure long before the COVID-19 lockdown. Karel Prinsloo / AFP via GettyImages

Zululand taxi industry mourns King Goodwill Zwelithini 

March 24, 2021

Browse by Tags

ACSA Arrive Alive Aviation BMW coronavirus COVID-19 Department of Transport Eskom featured Fikile Mbalula Gautrain Jacob Mamabolo Mbalula Mbombela minibus taxi Minibus taxis Minister Mbalula National Taxi Alliance NTA President Cyril Ramaphosa public transport RTIA RTMC SANRAL Santaco SA Taxi South Africa Taxi Indaba taxi industry Taxi Lekgotla taxis taxi violence Tender Toyota Transaction Capital Transport Transport Minister Transport Month Uber Volvo VW Commercial VW Crafter Women Women's Month Zimbabwe
Gibela Transport Magazine

GIBELA is a digital and print publication and a premier source of transport news on minibus taxis, aviation, e-hailing, cars, logistic transport, rail, the Gautrain, mobiity-as-a-service, (transport) technology and bus services.

MAIN MENU

  • Home
  • Airports
  • COVID-19
  • Editorial
  • Government
  • Rail
  • Taxis
  • Tenders

SPEAK TO US

  • Contact us
  • Advertise Here

© 2020 All copyrights reserved - Gibela Online Transport Magazine; part of Motho Media & Geko Publishing (Pty) Ltd.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Landing Page
  • Buy JNews
  • Support Forum
  • Contact Us

© 2020 All copyrights reserved - Gibela Online Transport Magazine; part of Motho Media & Geko Publishing (Pty) Ltd.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Create New Account!

Fill the forms bellow to register

*By registering into our website, you agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.
All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.